why does mesa report cards as 570/580/590
they are all different GPUs. which is it then?... thats kinda stupid imo

Last edited by Xpander on 24 July 2020 at 5:42 pm UTC

Quoting: The_Aquabat

Quoting: Xpanderwhy does mesa report cards as 570/580/590
they are all different GPUs. which is it then?... thats kinda stupid imo

because is the same silicon chipset just with more compute cores, stream processors enable, high grade chipset become 580/590, low quality chipsets become 570, same as CPUs that low quality chips end being low tier, they are just the same but with some deffective cores that get disabled. In the end is the same Polaris 10 chip.

That wasn't my point..I know what it is. But why it reports all those names..It could surely have the correct name by checking how many stream processors are enabled or whats the powerlimit or whatnot

Quoting: Xpander

Quoting: The_Aquabat

Quoting: Xpanderwhy does mesa report cards as 570/580/590
they are all different GPUs. which is it then?... thats kinda stupid imo

because is the same silicon chipset just with more compute cores, stream processors enable, high grade chipset become 580/590, low quality chipsets become 570, same as CPUs that low quality chips end being low tier, they are just the same but with some deffective cores that get disabled. In the end is the same Polaris 10 chip.

That wasn't my point..I know what it is. But why it reports all those names..It could surely have the correct name by checking how many stream processors are enabled or whats the powerlimit or whatnot

Or just by reading the device string reported from the host OS.

Quoting: The_AquabatJust received my new 5600 xt, Gigabyte Windforce version. Slight OC on the Gpu. Slight OC on the Cpu @3.8GHZ (Ryzen 2600)
it reports as a 5700xt, but it's a 5600xt.

this is also a 5600XT but it shows 5700XT:



No OC on my side.

I read about issues with it's vbios and the journey to flash it here and part two here but I still have to read into the details.

It feels like it's underperforming.

UPDATE:

I checked the bios with amdvbflash and the "latest" I find on techpowerup is XFX.RX5600XT.6144.200327.rom

    Product Name is :    NAVI10 A1/A2 D1990301 XLE 6GB 300e/875m 
    Device ID is    :    731F
    Bios Version    :    017.001.000.068.000000
    Bios P/N is     :    113-170WCNAVIXLE6
    Bios SSID       :    5710
    Bios SVID       :    1682
    Bios Date is    :    03/27/20 21:25 

while the vBios I extracted from the GPU is already

    Product Name is :    NAVI10 A1/A2 D18903 XLE 6GB 300e/875m 
    Device ID is    :    731F
    Bios Version    :    017.001.000.068.000000
    Bios P/N is     :    113-160WDNAVIXLE6
    Bios SSID       :    5710
    Bios SVID       :    1682
    Bios Date is    :    05/14/20 02:16 

So I guess I'm uptodate as long as I can not find any more recent vBios for this GPU.

Last edited by beko on 30 August 2020 at 2:46 pm UTC

Quoting: The_Aquabatseems Ok to me without OC I get 3400 or so...better than me. XFX is not precisely one of the best brands for AMD, likewise Gigabyte (the one I have). I think the best ones are Shappire, MSI and ASUS. Probably those ones can hit 3600 points without OC. Anyway it's just a trick because the cards performing better have higher clocks, so the OC I did would be like normal clocks for a Shappire card imo. In this cards the clocks are lower because the thermal solution is not upto the task.
Too bad that this cards cannot be bios modded, like polares did, if I understand correctly now you might brick your card if you flash a modded bios.

I read that it won't boot if you flash it without a valid signature. This is what the -rsa command is for on the flash util.

I researched somewhat and it looks like my precise model is XFX Radeon RX 5600 XT THICC III Pro 14Gbps 6GB GDDR6 and XFX has currently no more recent vBios so I'm good on this.

Interesting is that it has a vBios switch. The switch position closer to the power connector is "performance" mode while there is also a quiet mode. I wonder.. mine is currently on performance and in idle I have 15W consumption and 0 rpm on the fan. That sounds awesome to me :D

I'll get the OP updated today, have neglected it a bit

Also just realised that I never added my Vega 7 to it

Edit , Maybe not. Don't have write access to the spreadsheet

Here's mine, its only a year + late



Last edited by pete910 on 31 August 2020 at 9:09 am UTC

Quoting: pete910Edit , Maybe not. Don't have write access to the spreadsheet

PM your email to woox2k or me

Last edited by Xpander on 31 August 2020 at 9:53 am UTC

It's my turn,

With My RX 5600 XT, I tested with and without OC, with kernel 5.4 and 5.8.
+ comparison on Windows OpenGL and DirectX








Last edited by Vinouch on 6 September 2020 at 1:14 am UTC

New machine, same gfx card as before (score 3172). No OC.



Last edited by damarrin on 6 September 2020 at 7:59 am UTC

Quoting: The_Aquabat

Quoting: damarrinNew machine, same gfx card as before (score 3172). No OC.

so your score improved because of the cpu, mobo and ram?

Hard to say I guess? Different OS, newer kernel, driver, even newer benchmark version possibly. Quite a few variables there.