Latest 30 Comments

We hold that AI-generated content generally stands on dubious ethical and legal grounds, as it violates the copyright of creators whose work was scraped for the AI's training data set without their permission and without due attribution. Also, we find that it is frequently of low overall quality and/or is overly generic and fails to embrace requirements specific to Widelands.

Pull requests that have been generated by AI may in the future be closed without review.

🥰❤️

Absolutely love this. I think this is an excellent summary of the whole shebang. It's:

1- ethically wrong
2- legally wrong
3- created by stealing source material
4- resulting in low quality garbage

LOVE. I don't even know this game, but now I do, and I love it! Installing via the cachy repo right now and will give it a go.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: EhvisI don't hate "AI" as a tech. Machine learning/neural networks have had very good applications for decades since it is very effective in certain tasks. What I hate is the LLM/GenAI fueled hype machine that is created as a smokescreen over unrealistic promises of future potential. An attempt to try to bind as many people as they can before the house of cards collapses.

Nitpicking but yes. Obviously ML can be pretty great.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

I repeat a phrase of my late best friend peter: "This timeline was never intended to be used in an productive reality."

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: hardpenguinIf you are not hating on AI yet, you have a good reason to start now.

I don't hate "AI" as a tech. Machine learning/neural networks have had very good applications for decades since it is very effective in certain tasks. What I hate is the LLM/GenAI fueled hype machine that is created as a smokescreen over unrealistic promises of future potential. An attempt to try to bind as many people as they can before the house of cards collapses. Luckily this hard push is causing serious quality issues, which at least turns a significant portion of the public against it even beyond those wanting a new GPU or extra RAM.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Update: the article original noted both models were out out stock across all of Asia, it was amended as that's just for Japan. Also made it clearer it's the EU.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

This is one I'm very likely to get. While I'm probably not the biggest player of StS, I've still managed a good number of hours in the game over the years. And I'm not too worried about EA for these devs. Plus, a nice native Linux version made with Godot as a bonus.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

If you are not hating on AI yet, you have a good reason to start now.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

They touch on yet another important question here: dubious legal ground for AI "creations" and whether that can get an open source project in trouble. I imagine that in the field of code generation, the risk that AI output is just a "remix" of what it was trained on is especially big.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

I guess everyone knows [this tweet](https://x.com/jatinkrmalik/status/2009689523513618887) by now, but I still feel it needs to be quoted yet again:

Quoting: jatinThe reason why RAM has become four times more expensive is that a huge amount of RAM that has not yet been produced was purchased with non-existent money to be installed in GPUs that also have not yet been produced, in order to place them in data centers that have not yet been built, powered by infrastructure that may never appear, to satisfy demand that does not actually exist and to obtain profit that is mathematically impossible.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

I'd say this is fair. AI generated contributions have significant quality concerns so I'd probably block them as well if I was a maintainer.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Out of stock Steam Decks is just the beginning of our problems this year. Probably a lot of companies that will go out of business. Especially smaller PC part manufacturers as fewer and fewer customers will invest in new builds with prices as they are. It's very sad.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

If Valve teases new hardware, one should by stocks from manufacturers..

Sadly the producers of RAM and GPUs did not ramp up their production early enough. It should have been forsteeable for them, that the demand will rise fast.
But I guess, it is more safe to just wait and raise the prices, instead of investing in production machines in advance.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: mr-victory

Quoting: ScottCarammellstill waiting for that legitimate use case the technology is sure to get. I mean this is supposed to be the next motor vehicle or whatever, right? there's gotta be something huge right around the corner. not like this was all a giant, unbelievable waste of time, money, life and resources for absolutely nothing of value. that's impossible. the people on wall street said otherwise. they're supposed to be smart, right?

I'll drop another one: generative ai found an algorithm to multiply matrices faster

https://spectrum.ieee.org/matrix-multiplication-deepmind

But... again, this isn't what I'm talking about when I disparage genAI. From the article:

The scientists developed an AI system dubbed AlphaTensor based on AlphaZero, which they earlier developed to master chess, Go, and other games

They didn't use ChatGPT, or Claude, Gemini or Perplexity here. The kind of genAI that makes people's blood boil is very different from the useful, targeted ML instances that have existed for decades before all the genAI hype kicked off around 2022.

The actual technology of LLMs might have merit. But the over-hyping and over-investments in genAI... the lack of governance and ethical standards... the illegality of the training data... the inefficiency in the middle of a climate crisis... does not have merit.

And you know what? Finding one of two loosely related wins for LLMs won't balance the scales here anyway. Too much damage has already been done.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Now the last model (the 1TB OLED) is gone in germany, too. Scalpers already shifting gears to almost 1k. Sigh.
Anyone from germany remember the 1999s frequency auctions, where the mobile providers almost murdered themselves? Feels a bit like this.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: Hamish

Quoting: sarmadThis is unquestionably the most polished open source game. Prove me wrong.

I mean, the game is not finished even according to it development team. Although you could also say that just proves their ambition.

I would say The Battle for Wesnoth is a strong contender for "most polished" though. Less graphically intense sure but polish also implies stable and feature complete.

Definitely.
I'd also throw Mindustry into that ring.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: sarmadThis is unquestionably the most polished open source game. Prove me wrong.

I mean, the game is not finished even according to it development team. Although you could also say that just proves their ambition.

I would say The Battle for Wesnoth is a strong contender for "most polished" though. Less graphically intense sure but polish also implies stable and feature complete.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: memvirusSo I am asking a noob question:
Is there a way to have two versions of Lutris installed at the same time?

So I can try out just using automatic v0.5.20 but also have v0.5.14 installed if I am not happy and rather have some manual settings?

Yes. Just install through different package managements. Maybe your main is apt, and use Flatpak or Nix in addition to it - both supports downgrading and version pinning.

Distrobox is another option and the one that I recommend - just setup an Arch distrobox with a separate home, maybe add cachyos + chaotic-aur for convenience, and then install whatever you need.

Also, I think Conty comes with Lutris as well. Again, just set up a separate home (well, XDG_CONFIG_HOME and XDG_DATA_HOME) so it doesn't collide with your existing Lutris. Login to Lutris if you want to sync them, maybe.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: amataiIsn't GNULactic/Konquest a Linux exclusive ?

Also available on Mac apparently, so technically not.

https://apps.kde.org/konquest/

This is cheating, but...

https://cygwin.com/packages/summary/konquest.html

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: ScottCarammellstill waiting for that legitimate use case the technology is sure to get. I mean this is supposed to be the next motor vehicle or whatever, right? there's gotta be something huge right around the corner. not like this was all a giant, unbelievable waste of time, money, life and resources for absolutely nothing of value. that's impossible. the people on wall street said otherwise. they're supposed to be smart, right?

I'll drop another one: generative ai found an algorithm to multiply matrices faster

https://spectrum.ieee.org/matrix-multiplication-deepmind

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: PyratePlease, point to me where I suggested that you should use or not use anything. The lack of reading comprehension here is astounding.

I would agree, but I think we differ as to where it sits. Good day, sir.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

This is unquestionably the most polished open source game. Prove me wrong.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: TarosNice, didn't know Planescape: Torment had an Enhanced Edition. Got it. 🥰

Now, with even better torment!

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: M@GOidValve have big pockets and can afford to drag this in courts for years. But there are patent trolls going after the small companies and try to defeat them only trough legal costs.

I think that the legal system should be basically all public defenders/prosecutors. If you want to sue someone, you file the lawsuit, you get assigned a lawyer, the person you sue gets assigned a lawyer, they go at it, you both get assessed a fee based on ability to pay. If it's a complex case, maybe more lawyers, but you both get assigned the same amount of legal team. Maybe there's a step in there for a quick determination if the case is obviously frivolous it just gets dumped before the government has to spend money on you.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: eggrole

Quoting: Kimyrielle

Quoting: Mountain Man$150,000 seems too small of a penalty. They should have added another zero.

Even that isn't enough. Businesses like that have no right to exist. They should have seized the entire thing and shut them down.

I'm really torn over this. On one hand I'm pretty pro-capitalism

Quoting: eggroleWhy, oh why, did so many of us allow money worship to be such a central focus... :(

Um, capitalism. That's kind of the point.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: eggroleFurther, I think it is folly to underestimate your opponents. Sure those emails show a bunch of room temperature IQs, but I'm more concerned with who was behind organizing Epstein. The people in the emails are, IMHO, the worker bees of the actual oligarchs. Someone financed it all. Someone was/is using whatever happened as blackmail. Those are the real "masterminds" - the names we don't see.

I think what most people underestimate is the money itself. You don't need masterminds if you can buy the playing field. Somewhere back in the early 70s, the master plan for the wealthy class was set up. They asked this guy Powell to come up with ideas, his memo was distributed round particularly to the US Chamber of Commerce, they decided to get behind it, it wasn't even a secret, and they did it and it worked. The Powell memo is fairly easy to find.

And about all it comes down to is "We should, as rich business people, get together to fund propaganda. We should fund people to come up with PR ideas for our side, and fund outfits to popularize them, and make sure we own the media so the media will peddle those ideas for us." This is not a bad plan, but it's not mastermind stuff. And it can work . . . if you have all the money. Nobody who doesn't have all the money can make that plan work. And, there isn't really an equivalent not-having-money plan that matches it.

There isn't really a reason for oligarchs to come up with clever plans. They don't need to, the money itself is usually the winning hand that lets the most basic plays win.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: Caldathras

Quoting: princecThe latest drivers from Nvidia completely ruined my XFCE experience unfortunately, entirely breaking the compositor, which had to be turned off. Attempting to drop back down to the (known working) 570 drivers left me in "broken computer hell", booting to a black screen, which took a couple of days to fix. Grr. I am loathe to try the new 580 drivers as it's probably still the case that XFCE is broken.

I will probably have to accept that Mint really wants me to use Cinnamon instead, which I suppose is no great hardship.

I am running Linux Mint 22 XFCE with the 580 series driver. I haven't experienced the problems you've described. I'm on an older GPU, however. I also run at a resolution of no more than 1920x1080 (usually 1440x810 in game). Perhaps that accounts for the difference.

Maybe try @clatterfordslim's suggestion? Might work with the 580 series driver as well.

Quoting: jkaart

Quoting: clatterfordslim

Quoting: princecThe latest drivers from Nvidia completely ruined my XFCE experience unfortunately, entirely breaking the compositor, which had to be turned off.

You have to turn the inbuilt v_blank off inside of xfwm to fix the screen flickering, after installing the newish 590.48.01 driver.
Here is the fix, unless you already know then ignore.
xfconf-query -c xfwm4 -p /general/vblank_mode -s off
Then reboot your system. Switch on Pipeline Composition in NVIDIA-Settings and you won't have any more problems.

Have you give any source for this fix?

Originally Leo the AI companion in Brave-Browser came up with it, but here is where he got it from.
https://bbs.archlinux.org/viewtopic.php?id=311088

Scroll down the page you'll see someone had posted the solution. It worked for me too and have no more screen flickering.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Great. Opus Magnum felt like the perfect balance of hard and good from Zachtronics, being both very accessible and leaving ample room for fine optimizations. More content is great.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: Kimyrielle

Quoting: Mountain Man$150,000 seems too small of a penalty. They should have added another zero.

Even that isn't enough. Businesses like that have no right to exist. They should have seized the entire thing and shut them down.

I'm really torn over this. On one hand I'm pretty pro-capitalism (with the understanding that all -isms need some guardrails) but I'm also very much against owning "ideas". Maybe there could be some kind of middle ground where you can sue for patent infringment if you are actively using the patent in a product. But, if you aren't using it then you lose you ability to sue for infringment. Heck maybe even move the patent to the now producer of said patented product.

Still, it all is so tiresome trying to figure out a million laws/ways to stop everyone from screwing each other over. Why, oh why, did so many of us allow money worship to be such a central focus... :(

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Quoting: Caldathras

Quoting: g000hWell, Chrome Books (Google) and Mobile Phones (Google and Apple) are not far off being headless terminals. The public uses them for consuming content, most of their functionality relies on cloud services (e.g. WhatsApp, Instagram, iCloud, Google Maps, Google Docs, etc).

Not sure I agree here. My Android smartphone, for me, is effectively a minicomputer. I do not use it for any of the "functionality" you've listed here. No streaming. No games. No social media. I use it for visiting forums, online research, offline calendar & task management, recording notes, offline office functionality, etc. This is not all that different than my daily driver laptop. On top of that, I also take photographs and send and receive phone calls. These devices are what you make of them.

Yes, but you are the exception. You are using your phone like a computer and restricting yourself mostly to local apps - That is how I use mine. However, the vast majority of the public are using online services for everything - Spotify, Netflix, etc.

In my comment I was referring to a typical person, not a computer geek with privacy concerns.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment

Well okay, I guess, but that feels a bit pedantic? Did you read how they used genAI here? They designed their own ML model using medical data. Technically, okay, sure, that's genAI, fine. But it's hardly the kind of genAI that everyone is talking about and hating on. It's not plagiarising books, pirating material, talking kids into suicide or whatever.

It's probably also not quite the planet burning water hog either, because the data sets are so targeted.

Maybe you're right, and I'm the one being pedantic here, but I honestly don't feel like we should conflate these two things and thereby justify the car crash of genAI over-investment by pointing at fringe, targeted medical uses.

View this comment - View article - View full comments - Report this comment