Latest Comments

To be fair, it was not so much trolling as asking a question. There is a difference. I would not head the Twitter comment that much as everything on Twitter is borderline troll by it's very nature, but that was definitely not the way his thoughts were presented on reddit.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: HamishCarmack is discussing things with businessmen though, which part of the problem. See the quote I highlighted. Taken in those terms I can understand why he has decided upon the direction he has taken, even if it makes me dislike the Zenimax acquisition even more. I can also understand even more why TTimo jumped ship.

Still, as a side note, has anyone else here read David Kushner's excellent book Masters of Doom? I think that should be required reading for anyone before they attempt to make a character assassination of either Carmack or Romero.

If I had to choose official GNU/Linux releases or open source code releases I'd choose always the later. I'll only play Rage when it's released that way most probably. I understand that position and I think that nothing negative would be said about him if he didn't publish statements that work like trolling. It's his trolling that's getting him angry reactions. I don't think Zenimax can be made accountable for that.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

I just had a play for an hour, only with bots as i did not want to show myself up, it runs smooth and looks real nice, xubuntu 12.04 32bit, ATI Raiden HD 6870, the mouse movement feels so much smoother on linux then it did on windows vista (same computer dual boot), and not once did it lag/freeze really is smooth, did have some blue coloured screen flashes when round was over and score board displays and sometimes my gun moves up and down really fast again only after round was over and the scores where showing, gameplay wise it was really good with no display problems at all, and did i say REALLY SMOOTH, lol.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Carmack is discussing things with businessmen though, which part of the problem. See the quote I highlighted. Taken in those terms I can understand why he has decided upon the direction he has taken, even if it makes me dislike the Zenimax acquisition even more. I can also understand even more why TTimo jumped ship.

Still, as a side note, has anyone else here read David Kushner's excellent book Masters of Doom? I think that should be required reading for anyone before they attempt to make a character assassination of either Carmack or Romero.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

This comment from Carmack just proves he's thinking like a businessman, the big numbers is all that matters and we haven't still proved we can reach them:
http://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/17x0sh/john_carmack_asks_why_wine_isnt_good_enough/c89sfto

He focuses on GNU/Linux alone, avoiding the much broader picture of multi-platform development for a variety of Linux based systems. Users and developers would highly benefit from a standard multi-platform library layer, that layer can't be Wine and he doesn't really seem to be interested in such thing at all.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

I think people need to tone down some of the hate that is being thrown about though. He is not being as unreasonable as some people are making out. Read his reddit post:
http://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/17x0sh/john_carmack_asks_why_wine_isnt_good_enough/c89sfto

That is not to say that I agree with his WINE comments, but I think some of the bile that is making it's rounds around the net is uncalled for. Especially since people need to take into account this comment here:

QuoteHowever, I don’t think that a good business case can be made for officially supporting Linux for mainstream games today, and Zenimax doesn’t have any policy of “unofficial binaries” like Id used to have. I have argued for their value (mostly in the context of experimental Windows features, but Linux would also benefit), but my forceful internal pushes have been for the continuation of Id Software’s open source code releases, which I feel have broader benefits than unsupported Linux binaries.

And he is actually exactly right about the fact that the source code releases are more important - I would rather have access to a games source code be made available than a single port to a single platform any day. Especially since in doing so it decouples the games from Steamworks or any other potential forms of DRM. I am still waiting for the day I can play Rage natively on my machine without the Steamworks requirement, like what is possible with Doom3: BFG already. This idea I support fully

I do not support the idea of WINE as a primarily means for gaming however. I do use it and recognize it's value, but I am also well aware it's shortfalls. The sound is not working for me at the moment, and for the longest time doing anything with it (like launching FirstClass so I could send off my school assignments) would bork my sound server (it has now thankfully settled down somewhat and simply does not work without borking anything else). And there are so many other technical and practical reasons why his proposal is a bad idea, from increased overheard, worse support, and of course the message it sends out.

TTimo said it well. :)

View this comment - View article - View full comments

The argument against this guy is simple:  using wine discourages game developers from making real Linux ports.  Real Linux ports mean better support.  id has done nothing but spew garbage from their mouths over the past year about Linux, so I wish they would shut up already.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

It's surprising seeing someone so technical as Carmack saying that, although maybe not that surprising since he's been praising things like Direct3D. He sometimes seems more commercially focused than technically.

Wine is a wrong idea for anything serious simply because is a reverse-engineering project. It will always lag behind the real product and will fail to be a perfect replacement. It does very weird things to try to work around some serious challenges with no optimal solution.

In the past, Carmack gained a reputation as someone pushing the envelope for technical excelence, now this comment makes him look bad. Problems with AMD drivers? Did he stop developing Quake2 or Quake3 because of drivers problems or did he stop using DirectX when it didn't work? No, he pushed for these to work better.

What about Rage for the iPhone? It sounds like a joke, but he did it.

He used to say that making cross-platform programming helped find issues in the code and fix them, so it made better code. Maybe he's found better ways to do that but I think going multi-platform is working for many indie developers, it's maybe easier than ever, it's profitable, it helps your sales in a world no longer dominated by Windows and with several Linux based systems emerging. Doesn't he see that?

For me it's just that he doesn't need it, he already earns lots money supporting the most popular platforms and some others per request. He goes where the big money is. Good for him but I don't see the need for excuses.

I don't play Wine games, I used it for some old games but now I prefer to play native games and support developers that care about their product quality and user satisfaction.

Limbo started with problems but they finally fixed it. It plays really well for me and I didn't mind doing an exception since I had already bought it, but I wonder if they wouldn't have been better doing a native port. Maybe it wouldn't have been much more work and wouldn't have looked like a hack.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Quoting: s_dI thought that the Desurium client RC1 already solved this by exposing 32-bit games to 32-bit client builds, and exposing 32-bit & 64-bit games to 64-bit builds.  Better ask Cheese, Liam!  He's all up in that 

Interesting... I remember reading on Ubuntu Forums that Desurium lacked the ability to filter games according to your platform. I should definitely give it a try, then.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

I thought that the Desurium client RC1 already solved this by exposing 32-bit games to 32-bit client builds, and exposing 32-bit & 64-bit games to 64-bit builds.  Better ask Cheese, Liam!  He's all up in that :)

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Frag yeah! Installed it as soon as I saw your tweet.
Even though I suck at CSS still think it's an epic game. (and something that'll be on my school pc in no-time ;) )

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Beginning to wonder if Carmack is just trolling now

View this comment - View article - View full comments

And yes, I certainly did vote!  + OGL3, + 64-bit only, + 8GB RAM, - new computer (in case anyone cares).

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Hm.  Big surprise, the poll is coming up to around 20% "no" and 80% "yes" (currently 17/83%), which coincidentally is approximately the split on the stretch goal poll, where we requested Linux & Mac support.

In fact, it appears to have degraded some from the 20-21% during the campaign, as Mac & Linux fans' attention has wandered elsewhere.  Why would anyone expect that to change?  First, it's a poll of those who (for the most part) have already pledged for Windows, and the lion's share of them wouldn't notice whether it's DX11 or OGL3.

My prediction is that Roberts will point to these numbers to show that there "wasn't enough community interest" if they're ever asked to justify why he chose the path he did (which will obviously not be portability).

><

View this comment - View article - View full comments

i looked those few days ago and im still wondering that were are the other linux distros counted?
i mean there are lots of Fedora, Debian and Arch users, as well as Gentoo and Mint and Suse

will Mint be Counted as Ubuntu? when i used Mint it had its own name under the hardware info.
same with my current Arch Linux, it shows the name there.

so my bet is that half of the Other Category is other linux distros and half of it is the rest of the weird operating systems/wine..

Edit: also as time passes im sure they will make the info to count the linux distros as Linux and Linux 64bit.
then have a separate Linux category where all the distro usage is counted.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Done! I really wish to see Far Cry one day on Linux.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Please report bugs to the bugs forum and tell me how to reproduce.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

offtopic: liamdawe can you fix your site as well. or maybe only i have that bug.
every time new replay(comment) has been entered into the news article and i refresh the page it throws me error which asks me to go back to the index and then i can check the link again.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Their main website annoys me as well, the fact that I have to manually subscribe to a game to receive news in my notifications about it even when I own it as well.
When you buy a game you should be then subscribed to it.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

There's no way to change your selected platform on Desura's official client, right? Maybe uninstalling the 64bit client and installing the 32bit one? (just feeling too lazy to try it myself...)

For what it's worth, here's the complete list of 32bit-only games that don't show without tweaking your platform selection (13 in total):

· Battlemass
· Blue Libra 2
· CAFÉ 0 ~The Drowned Mermaid~
· Cube MetalHeart - Sauerbraten Extended
· Exodus Wars: Fractured Empire
· Incursion
· Livalink
· Revenge Of The Cats: Ethernet
· Running with Rifles
· Solar War
· Super Space Rubbish
· The Real Texas
· Zombie Grinder

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Just FYI all commenters, indiecity will be doing it in a much more sane way and just putting 32bit or 64bit in the system requirements area and not split them into two platforms :)

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Holy cow you are right, good find but honestly only including Linux 32bit selection from a link inside a real small pop up most will ignore...sigh.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Article updated with a view from TTimo former id employee!

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Its found by selecting a platform at the top bar. It'll pop up saying Now browsing "platform" if you want you can manage your platforms which is linked to that page.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Yeah I updated the article to have it :), can't see it linked from anywhere on the Desura website though.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

how do u change that
i only see option to linux64, windows and mac

edit: nvm that link in the first post

View this comment - View article - View full comments

I didn't even know that existed which is bad, I will change mine now so I don't miss anything but my god what a stupid way to do it.

I have now changed it and more games have appeared thank god, although now it doesn't highlight my platform select at all on the top right on the Desura website, they really need to sort this out.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

I actually noticed this a long time ago. Fixed it the same way as avarisclari: went to "manage my platform selection" and selected 32bit instead of 64bit.

I could be wrong, but I believe someone did make a topic in their forums about this before. I didn't see much reason to repeat post cause, let's be honest, the Desura website desperately needs an upgrade anyway. Unlike the Desurium client which is coming along nicely, the service-side is falling behind. Showing 32bit/64bit is only one of their problems...

View this comment - View article - View full comments

Your where talking about Desura, it has no DRM and that is what I stated.

View this comment - View article - View full comments

From one side, this is a really good idea. Why? Look at the Mac - on this market, huge companies use Cider (utility from TransGaming which is basically something like CrossOver/Wine) to release official game ports. Companies like EA, Ubisoft, Activision and Bioware! Why wouldn't this work in case of Wine? This is also how PlayOnLinux works - it uses precise Wine version with precise settings, ensuring functioning on any Linux machine.

The failure with Limbo in Humble Indie Bundle V occured most likely just because they didn't beta-test the port properly before.

There are of course many drawbacks of this solution as well. Like, most of all, making game developers ignoring Linux as an independent platform. And, of course, the risk of Microsoft sueing CodeWeavers (CrossOver/Wine developers) for abusing on of their patents.

EDIT:

Oh, and here is the list of Cider-powered games: http://transgaming.com/cider/games

View this comment - View article - View full comments