Since the level of toxic posts in the community has sadly risen, I have now rolled out the moderation queue approvals process that was in place on the forum into article comments too.
If you have seen a message above the comments box about being in the list, you can mostly ignore it. A side-effect of it, was that if you hadn't posted in the forum 3+ times (and the posts were approved), but you did make plenty of article comments, it would see you as having to go through the approvals process. I have since adjusted it to remove any older users from the mod queue who made at least 3 article comments.
It's in place for all new users, so we catch spam (and stupid troll accounts) and remove/ban before it hits live and annoys us and you.
I've also made it so I can force naughty users into an "always on" mod queue, so we can remove completely idiotic and toxic comments before they are posted. Hopefully this will make a few users re-think their attitude, rather than us having to outright ban people.
Does this affect your freedom of speech if I think you're being naughty and idiotic and force the queue to always be on for you? No. Very few sites don't moderate comments, don't be silly.
Part of my commitment to keeping this community as fun as possible for all.
If you have seen a message above the comments box about being in the list, you can mostly ignore it. A side-effect of it, was that if you hadn't posted in the forum 3+ times (and the posts were approved), but you did make plenty of article comments, it would see you as having to go through the approvals process. I have since adjusted it to remove any older users from the mod queue who made at least 3 article comments.
It's in place for all new users, so we catch spam (and stupid troll accounts) and remove/ban before it hits live and annoys us and you.
I've also made it so I can force naughty users into an "always on" mod queue, so we can remove completely idiotic and toxic comments before they are posted. Hopefully this will make a few users re-think their attitude, rather than us having to outright ban people.
Does this affect your freedom of speech if I think you're being naughty and idiotic and force the queue to always be on for you? No. Very few sites don't moderate comments, don't be silly.
Part of my commitment to keeping this community as fun as possible for all.
Some you may have missed, popular articles from the last month:
All posts need to follow our rules. For users logged in: please hit the Report Flag icon on any post that breaks the rules or contains illegal / harmful content. Guest readers can email us for any issues.
There's a link to the rules above the comment box ;)
Oh and as for trolls, I have no issues removing them. Anyone dancing around rules being an idiot deserves to be removed.
Last edited by Liam Dawe on 22 May 2017 at 7:59 am UTC
Oh and as for trolls, I have no issues removing them. Anyone dancing around rules being an idiot deserves to be removed.
Last edited by Liam Dawe on 22 May 2017 at 7:59 am UTC
0 Likes
There's a link to the rules above the comment box ;)
Oh and as for trolls, I have no issues removing them. Anyone dancing around rules being an idiot deserves to be removed.
Well there we go then :) Typical of me - it's two inches from my nose and I somehow miss it :). They look pretty straight forward. If you add anything, I would suggest adding a rule about direct threats.
0 Likes
Does this affect your freedom of speech if I think you're being naughty and idiotic and force the queue to always be on for you? No.
XKCD said it best. https://xkcd.com/1357/
Last edited by artvandelay440 on 22 May 2017 at 2:34 pm UTC
3 Likes, Who?
I am now bookmarking that XKCD.Does this affect your freedom of speech if I think you're being naughty and idiotic and force the queue to always be on for you? No.
XKCD said it best. https://xkcd.com/1357/
1 Likes, Who?
Hmm, as I am following this site for quite some time now and love to read the comments, I can only remember a handful of "toxic posts" in the past year or so. I guess that is due to moderation ;) ?
Anyway, if it is a problem for you as the site owner, and steals time which could be spent for other things, do it, it is your right and the community benefits from it too. So go on.
Anyway, if it is a problem for you as the site owner, and steals time which could be spent for other things, do it, it is your right and the community benefits from it too. So go on.
1 Likes, Who?
I haven't really noticed any toxic comments, but I'm one of those people who have "thick skin" as middle name.
0 Likes
Is "thick skin" really a great thing to have? Doesn't it just mean giving awful stuff a pass? I would imagine that's not a great trait for someone moderating, and trying to make the site welcoming for a broad range of people.
3 Likes, Who?
Is "thick skin" really a great thing to have? Doesn't it just mean giving awful stuff a pass? I would imagine that's not a great trait for someone moderating, and trying to make the site welcoming for a broad range of people.Aryvandaar didn't actually make a value claim about thick skin (let alone a claim about its utility for a moderator), just said that's what he had. Seems plausible. I'm generally willing to assume most people's self-descriptions are true unless they prove them otherwise in the next sentence (which happens surprisingly often).
1 Likes, Who?
Aryvandaar didn't actually make a value claim about thick skin (let alone a claim about its utility for a moderator), just said that's what he had.
Are you sure Kels didn't just make a general comment to everyone who value thick skin?
I for one agree wholeheartedly with Kels view. Makes me want to hug him or her. <3
Last edited by AlveKatt on 24 May 2017 at 2:24 pm UTC
1 Likes, Who?
Is "thick skin" really a great thing to have? Doesn't it just mean giving awful stuff a pass? I would imagine that's not a great trait for someone moderating, and trying to make the site welcoming for a broad range of people.Frankly, I find it to be a really stupid term. Mainly used by people who look over things people put on the internet with the intent to stir up trouble and hurt people.
It's a dumb saying. Either way, I don't care if people think I am "thin skinned", I am who I am.
0 Likes
It's a dumb saying. Either way, I don't care if people think I am "thin skinned", I am who I am.
You're squid-skinned.
1 Likes, Who?
But yes, as AlveKatt said I meant it in the more general sense rather than anything specifically about Aryvandaar. I mean I don't even know them, they're probably a lovely person. It's more that it's a phrase I've heard a lot, usually in the context of putting people down for being "thin skinned" which I think is kind of awful.
More specifically for moderators though, whoever's doing the moderating should be prepared for a certain amount of heat directed at them. Moderators will always be seen as power-hungry/mad, unfair, biased, and any number of awful things by some users. They'll always have people complaining about them, so you have to be ready for that. But at the same time, you have to be sensitive to more than just the most "thick-skinned" members of your commenter base. It's a balancing act, but a worthwhile one.
More specifically for moderators though, whoever's doing the moderating should be prepared for a certain amount of heat directed at them. Moderators will always be seen as power-hungry/mad, unfair, biased, and any number of awful things by some users. They'll always have people complaining about them, so you have to be ready for that. But at the same time, you have to be sensitive to more than just the most "thick-skinned" members of your commenter base. It's a balancing act, but a worthwhile one.
1 Likes, Who?
Is "thick skin" really a great thing to have? Doesn't it just mean giving awful stuff a pass? I would imagine that's not a great trait for someone moderating, and trying to make the site welcoming for a broad range of people.
Without saying too much about it, I've been bullied most of my school years. By ever reason I should have a thin skin, but I simply decided that I wasn't going to be a victim and would do everything in my power to make my life better. I can see why people have thin skin, but I don't understand it. Sure, people can be rude and unhelpful, but in the end it is you who decide how to deal with what is said to you.
The moment someone starts inciting to violence or something like that, I'm the first one to speak up how wrong it is, but that is not what it is about here.
This is why I simply don't care. I have better things to set my mind towards. Then there is the fact that I used to be a "Batman" Troll (meaning that I specifically targeted assholes and those most people hated in communities).
Last edited by Aryvandaar on 25 May 2017 at 9:25 am UTC
0 Likes
See more from me