Latest Comments by CatKiller
Space Marine 2 fixes online for Steam Deck but may need launch option on desktop Linux
8 October 2024 at 2:29 pm UTC Likes: 3
8 October 2024 at 2:29 pm UTC Likes: 3
QuoteHowever, like we've seen from a few games over the last year, desktop Linux users have issues since the game appears to look for the Steam Deck specifically. To get around it you need to spoof your desktop Linux PC to appear as a Steam Deck with this Steam launch optionIt's so weird that game devs do that, especially when there are fewer Deck users on Steam than non-Deck Linux users on Steam. It's just so sloppy.
Epic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
6 October 2024 at 7:09 am UTC Likes: 1
Note that it's not just that they don't want publishers to specifically rip off Steam customers on price, they also don't want them to shaft Steam customers on content. If, say, a game bought on PlayStation has a PlayStation exclusive item, and bought on Xbox has an Xbox exclusive item, and bought on EGS has an EGS exclusive item, then they for sure want the game bought on Steam to have an equivalent Steam item.
As to whether games can be sold cheaper on EGS (or wherever), they absolutely can.
6 October 2024 at 7:09 am UTC Likes: 1
Quoting: pleasereadthemanualThreatening to de-list a publisher's game from Steam if they do not bring the price down to match the game's price on other stores has a direct impact on other stores—namely, Epic Games Store (EGS).
Note that it's not just that they don't want publishers to specifically rip off Steam customers on price, they also don't want them to shaft Steam customers on content. If, say, a game bought on PlayStation has a PlayStation exclusive item, and bought on Xbox has an Xbox exclusive item, and bought on EGS has an EGS exclusive item, then they for sure want the game bought on Steam to have an equivalent Steam item.
As to whether games can be sold cheaper on EGS (or wherever), they absolutely can.
Epic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
6 October 2024 at 4:29 am UTC Likes: 1
What Valve have said is that they want their customers to get a fair deal, and if it looks like they aren't they would like to find out why and if there's anything they can do to change that. Is that "getting a good deal for your customers" or is that "monopolistic price-fixing"? Given that it's publishers that set their own prices, and you can find games cheaper than on Steam, is there any actual harm from Valve's actions even if their intent was super nefarious? Those are the kinds of questions that the court would have to find answers for.
6 October 2024 at 4:29 am UTC Likes: 1
Quoting: pleasereadthemanualI agree with all of this, though assuming all of these emails are factual, I don't think any amount of context will change my opinion. But we'll see.
What Valve have said is that they want their customers to get a fair deal, and if it looks like they aren't they would like to find out why and if there's anything they can do to change that. Is that "getting a good deal for your customers" or is that "monopolistic price-fixing"? Given that it's publishers that set their own prices, and you can find games cheaper than on Steam, is there any actual harm from Valve's actions even if their intent was super nefarious? Those are the kinds of questions that the court would have to find answers for.
Quoting: pleasereadthemanualDo you have a link to Valve's rebuttal? I'd be interested in reading it.It's the first two attachments (reports from two expert witnesses) on the motion to exclude testimony of Dr Schwarz, as I recall. The first one is about 300 pages. It's a while since I read it. Um... these two, I think: Attachment 1 and Attachment 2
Epic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
4 October 2024 at 3:29 pm UTC
Plaintiffs have to throw every accusation they can, since they can't generally add them afterwards, and then they have to dig around to find something that might support their position; the court case is what determines whether there's any validity to it.
Media and commentators love to look at accusations of the plaintiff, since they get to go first and they necessarily have to throw in the most salacious stuff, whereas actual court cases are really long and kinda boring.
4 October 2024 at 3:29 pm UTC
Quoting: pleasereadthemanualI won't pretend to understand the specifics here (and there are a lot of documents to sift through), but my understanding is that these are direct quotes from emails. I think the only way Valve could come out of this cleanly is if the emails were completely fabricated.Oh, I'm sure they were excerpts of actual emails sent from actual people at Valve. Discovery dredges up a tonne of stuff - from other companies, too, as you noted. The court will look at the context of the documents, and both sides will make their arguments, and the court will decide whether it shows a policy or pattern of wrongdoing, or whether it's just perfectly fine course of business stuff.
But it does seem early to conclude whether that is evidence or not.
Plaintiffs have to throw every accusation they can, since they can't generally add them afterwards, and then they have to dig around to find something that might support their position; the court case is what determines whether there's any validity to it.
Media and commentators love to look at accusations of the plaintiff, since they get to go first and they necessarily have to throw in the most salacious stuff, whereas actual court cases are really long and kinda boring.
Epic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
4 October 2024 at 10:25 am UTC
4 October 2024 at 10:25 am UTC
Quoting: pleasereadthemanualIn the Exhibit 85 document on Aug 23, 2024, there is some reference to emails from Valve about price parity that is being submitted as evidence.For context, the plaintiff's expert witness produced a report saying what the plaintiff wanted; Valve's expert witness (compellingly, IMO) said that plaintiff's report was terrible and shouldn't be allowed in the case, and the document you're looking at is plaintiffs arguing that their export report should totally be allowed. None of it's actually in the case as evidence yet. Both sides are still in the "what is this case actually about" stage. Although, to be fair, once "what a case is actually about" is decided in anti-trust cases, the outcome tends to follow directly - hence the years of haggling before that point.
Epic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
3 October 2024 at 5:44 pm UTC
Maybe some evidence of that will turn up, but it hasn't yet.
3 October 2024 at 5:44 pm UTC
Quoting: pleasereadthemanualThere's been no evidence that that's a thing that they've done.Quoting: LoudTechieOn the anti-trust stuffWhat about the price parity enforcement Valve has been doing?
Maybe some evidence of that will turn up, but it hasn't yet.
Epic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
2 October 2024 at 12:50 am UTC Likes: 3
2 October 2024 at 12:50 am UTC Likes: 3
Quoting: KithopI'll echo the sentiment here though: good news for publishers, but they're doing *nothing* for consumers, so why should we care?Their plan is to starve Steam users of games, so you should probably care. There's definitely no reason to welcome it, of course.
Epic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
2 October 2024 at 12:45 am UTC Likes: 1
You'd have to show that Unreal Engine had a dominant market position in game engines, and that they were using that to unfairly tie the Epic Games Store. It's a feasible argument, but not a slam dunk.
2 October 2024 at 12:45 am UTC Likes: 1
Quoting: ElectricPrismQuoteEpic Games reduce their cut for Unreal Engine games for same-day Epic Store launches
I'm pretty sure that is illegal and that other companies have been litigated against for this kind of thing.
You'd have to show that Unreal Engine had a dominant market position in game engines, and that they were using that to unfairly tie the Epic Games Store. It's a feasible argument, but not a slam dunk.
Steam's Turn-Based RPG Fest is now live
1 October 2024 at 9:32 am UTC Likes: 1
1 October 2024 at 9:32 am UTC Likes: 1
Quoting: KlaasYeah... Strong, charismatic, good with weapons and first aid but otherwise not too bright. Just how it turned out. Till I noticed, at least, and then I leaned into it.Quoting: CatKillerI realised partway through the second game that the character I'd created was basically Xena.You only realized that after one and a half games?
Steam's Turn-Based RPG Fest is now live
1 October 2024 at 5:51 am UTC Likes: 2
1 October 2024 at 5:51 am UTC Likes: 2
Quoting: neolithOh, I should give them a try then. I've gotten two of them in a bundle I think, but I've never looked into them let alone on the Deck.The trackpads are super comfy for it. I don't generally go for RPGs, but those ones grabbed me. In part, I suspect, because I could just do a bit as and when on the sofa rather than having it be a big time commitment. I realised partway through the second game that the character I'd created was basically Xena.
- Fedora KDE gets approval to be upgraded to sit alongside Fedora Workstation
- Steam gets new tools for game devs to offer players version switching in-game
- Palworld dev details the patents Nintendo and The Pokemon Company are suing for
- Sony say their PSN account requirement on PC is so you can enjoy their games 'safely'
- AYANEO 3 now officially announced with AMD Ryzen AI 9 HX 370 and HDR OLED
- > See more over 30 days here
-
Mesa 24.2.7 out now and Mesa 24.3 may come sooner than …
- redneckdrow -
Mesa 24.2.7 out now and Mesa 24.3 may come sooner than …
- whizse -
Mesa 24.2.7 out now and Mesa 24.3 may come sooner than …
- axredneck -
Mesa 24.2.7 out now and Mesa 24.3 may come sooner than …
- redneckdrow -
Epic roguelike Caves of Qud now has a proper tutorial
- Jarmer - > See more comments
- Who wants a free GOG key for Dishonored?
- poke86 - No more posting on X / Twitter
- Liam Dawe - Steam and offline gaming
- damarrin - Weekend Players' Club 10/11/2024
- Pengling - Upped the limit on article titles
- eldaking - See more posts
View cookie preferences.
Accept & Show Accept All & Don't show this again Direct Link